A clear sign that you are in the presence of a true leader

A manager talks to their team in the workplace – trust, psychological safety and effective leadership

True leadership is recognised not when everything goes to plan, but when things go wrong. That is when it becomes clear whether people are afraid of their manager or trust them. And whether their presence creates additional tension or helps the team find a solution.

Imagine a typical situation at work. An important project is running late, the client is unhappy, and the team is already under pressure. At the meeting, it becomes clear that a serious mistake has been made.

What happens next?

In one scenario, the manager starts looking for someone to blame. The conversation quickly turns into a series of excuses, defensive reactions and attempts to shift the blame elsewhere. People are careful about what they say, whilst some prefer to remain silent.

In the other scenario, the manager asks a few questions: What exactly happened? What did we fail to anticipate? How can we minimise the consequences? What do we need to change to prevent this from happening again?

In both cases, the problem is the same. The difference lies in the environment the leader creates.

One of the clearest signs of mature leadership is the ability to create conditions in which people can be open, take responsibility and work together, without fear of humiliation or unfair punishment.

Why do people keep problems to themselves?

In most organisations, staff do not necessarily keep information to themselves because they are uninterested.

Sometimes they remain silent because they have learnt that candour comes at a price.

They may have been publicly criticised in the past for asking an awkward question. They may have received a negative reaction when they admitted a mistake. Or they may have seen a colleague punished for expressing a different opinion.

Gradually, people begin to weigh up not only what is the right thing to say, but also what personal consequences this might have.

In this way, organisations lose something extremely valuable – access to accurate information about their own problems.

Mistakes do not disappear when people stop talking about them. They simply remain hidden for longer.

This mechanism is directly linked to the concept of psychological safety.

Psychological safety – the foundation of effective teams

In 1999, Harvard psychologist Amy Edmondson published a study that established psychological safety as a key concept in organisational psychology.

She defines it as a shared belief amongst team members that the environment is safe for taking interpersonal risks.

In practice, this means being able to ask a question, admit that one does not know something, offer a different opinion or point out a problem without fear of being humiliated or rejected.

Edmundson’s study, conducted amongst 51 work teams, established a link between psychological safety and learning-oriented behaviour.

Subsequent meta-analyses confirm that psychological safety is linked to a number of important organisational outcomes, including information sharing, engagement and team effectiveness.

But there is an important caveat here.

Psychological safety does not mean a lack of discipline, low standards or an exemption from responsibility.
It means that people can discuss problems openly, whilst continuing to take responsibility for their actions and results.

In fact, it is precisely the combination of high standards and psychological safety that creates the conditions for learning and development.

Trust is built not through words, but through behaviour

Almost every manager would say that trust is important.

But employees do not judge leadership solely on the basis of the organisation’s official messages. They observe the day-to-day behaviour of the people who manage them.

What happens when someone disagrees with their manager?

How are difficult tasks allocated?

Who receives recognition for successes?

How are mistakes dealt with?

Are promises kept?

It is precisely these situations that gradually build or destroy trust.

A meta-analysis by Kurt Durks and Donald Ferin, published in the *Journal of Applied Psychology*, shows that trust in leaders is linked to job satisfaction, organisational commitment and other important work-related attitudes and behaviours.

Of particular importance is the perception that the manager is fair and consistent.

That is why trust cannot be built through a one-off motivational event or a corporate values campaign. It is formed through numerous daily interactions.

A true leader can admit that they do not know

One of the paradoxes of management is that the higher a person’s position, the more strongly they may feel obliged to have an answer to every question.

But a complex working environment rarely allows for this.

Technological change, economic uncertainty and the interdependence of different functions mean that no manager has all the necessary information.

Sometimes the most helpful response is to say:

‘I don’t know the answer at the moment. Let’s look into it.’

Or:

‘That decision didn’t produce the expected result. We need to find out why.’

Such behaviour does not imply a lack of competence. When combined with determination and accountability, it demonstrates a realistic assessment of the limits of one’s own knowledge.

It also sets an important example: if a manager can acknowledge uncertainty, staff will find it easier to speak openly about their own difficulties.

And this is particularly valuable in organisations where mistakes can have serious consequences.

Leadership also influences stress in the workplace

We usually associate stress with heavy workloads, tight deadlines and high demands.

But the way people are managed can also be a source of tension.

An manager’s unpredictable behaviour, contradictory instructions, public humiliation, a lack of feedback and the constant threat of punishment can all increase psychological strain.

When a person does not know how their manager will react, even routine work situations can become a source of anxiety.

Conversely, clear expectations, fair treatment, the opportunity to participate in decision-making and accessible support are important organisational resources.

This does not mean that a good leader can eliminate all sources of stress.

But it does mean that leadership style can both amplify and mitigate the impact of existing difficulties.

Here, it is important to distinguish between individual resilience and organisational responsibility.

It is not enough to train staff on how to manage stress if management practices continually create conditions of overload, uncertainty and conflict.

The prevention of psychosocial risks also begins with the way in which work is organised and managed.

The most important test for a leader is the difficult conversation

It is easy to be considerate and well-meaning when results are good.

It is much harder to maintain respect for people when we have to communicate an unpleasant decision, set a boundary or discuss poor performance.

It is precisely at these moments that leadership becomes apparent.

An effective leader does not shy away from difficult conversations. They do not put them off indefinitely, nor do they hide the problem behind vague phrasing.

Nor, however, do they use fear as their primary management tool.

They state the facts, explain expectations, listen to different points of view and seek a solution that balances organisational goals with respect for the individual.

For example, there is a significant difference between:

‘You’ve failed yet again. I don’t know why I rely on you at all.’

and

‘The result doesn’t match what was agreed. Let’s look at the reasons, what was within your control and what needs to change.’

In both cases, the issue of responsibility is raised.

But only the second approach creates a real opportunity for a constructive conversation.

A strong leader does not create dependent people

Sometimes managers measure their own importance by how many decisions pass through them.

They are constantly involved, answering every question, fine-tuning every detail and intervening in every task.

From the outside, this may appear to be a high level of commitment.

But when a team cannot make decisions without the constant approval of a single person, the organisation becomes dependent and vulnerable.

True leadership involves the ability to develop the competence and autonomy of others.

This means providing clear responsibilities, real authority, access to information and opportunities for learning.

It is not about a lack of control, but about control that is commensurate with the team’s maturity and the complexity of the task.

A leader does not lose authority when their team members become more competent.

On the contrary – the team’s ability to function successfully without constant intervention is one of the most meaningful outcomes of good leadership.

How can we tell whether people really trust their manager?

We cannot always gauge trust by asking the direct question, ‘Do you trust your manager?’.

People sometimes give socially desirable answers, especially if they doubt the confidentiality of the survey.

A few practical questions may be more revealing:

  • Can employees report problems before they turn into crises?
  • Do they feel free to ask questions and express differing opinions?
  • Do they understand how and why important decisions are made?
  • Do they receive fair and timely feedback?
  • Can they admit a mistake without fear of being humiliated?
  • Do they have enough autonomy to carry out their responsibilities?

The answers do not provide a complete assessment of leadership, but they can reveal how the management environment functions.

If employees consistently remain silent, avoid giving feedback or do not dare to raise issues, this is a sign that warrants attention.

And this is not necessarily because people are not sufficiently engaged, but because the organisation itself may have created conditions in which candour is perceived as a risk.

Good leadership is not a personality trait, but a daily practice

We often talk about leaders as though they possess a certain innate quality that sets them apart from others.

But leadership involves behaviour, skills and decisions that can be developed.

A person may be an exceptionally competent professional and yet struggle with managing people.

They may have a strong vision but be unable to give feedback.

They may be a good communicator, but fail to recognise the effect of their own behaviour on the team.

That is why developing leadership requires more than simply learning motivational techniques.

It requires self-awareness, the ability to regulate one’s own reactions, an understanding of human behaviour, and a willingness to change.

It is particularly important for a manager to recognise how their own stress affects their decision-making and communication.

When a leader is chronically overworked, this can hinder their ability to listen, assess the situation calmly and respond consistently.

This is why ensuring leadership effectiveness also involves managing one’s own workload, rather than simply managing the performance of others.

A true leader is recognised by how they react when things go wrong

Go back to the situation at the start.

The important project is running late. A mistake has been made. The team is under pressure.

At this point, the manager can either exacerbate the fear or create the conditions for a solution.

They may look for someone to blame or clarify responsibilities.

They may suppress uncomfortable information or use it to improve the work.

They can show that their authority is more important than the result, or that collective success requires everyone’s competence.

The difference does not lie in whether the leader is strict or well-meaning, charismatic or reserved, outgoing or introverted.

A true leader is not someone with whom problems never arise. They are the person with whom problems can be identified, discussed and resolved, without people losing their dignity.
It is precisely at such moments that trust ceases to be merely a fine-sounding word in a company’s values and becomes a real management practice.


Scientific sources

  1. Edmondson, A. C. (1999). Psychological Safety and Learning Behaviour in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383.
    https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
  2. Dirks, K. T., & Ferrin, D. L. (2002). Trust in Leadership: Meta-Analytic Findings and Implications for Research and Practice. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87(4), 611–628.
    https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.87.4.611
  3. Frazier, M. L., Fainshmidt, S., Klinger, R. L., Pezeshkan, A., & Vracheva, V. (2017). Psychological Safety: A Meta-Analytic Review and Extension. Personnel Psychology, 70(1), 113–165.
    https://doi.org/10.1111/peps.12183
  4. Breevaart, K., Bakker, A. B., Hetland, J., Demerouti, E., Olsen, O. K., & Espevik, R. (2014). Daily Transactional and Transformational Leadership and Daily Employee Engagement. Journal of Occupational and Organisational Psychology, 87(1), 138–157.
    https://doi.org/10.1111/joop.12041
  5. Mayer, R. C., Davis, J. H., & Schoorman, F. D. (1995). An Integrative Model of Organisational Trust. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 709–734.
    https://doi.org/10.2307/258792
  6. World Health Organisation. (2022).
    WHO Guidelines on Mental Health at Work.

    https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240053052

  7. World Health Organisation & International Labour Organisation. (2022).
    Mental Health at Work: Policy Brief.

    https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240057944

  8. International Organisation for Standardisation. (2021).
    ISO 45003:2021 – Occupational Health and Safety Management: Psychological Health and Safety at Work – Guidelines for Managing Psychosocial Risks.

    https://www.iso.org/standard/64283.html