What makes a person a good leader? Innate qualities, the ability to make decisions, or the way they treat people? Over the last hundred years, ideas about leadership have changed significantly. We have gradually moved away from the idea of a strong leader who controls and commands, towards models based on inspiration, adaptability, trust and team development.
Imagine two managers leading teams with similar tasks.
The first sets clear goals, monitors progress and takes action when results fall short of expectations.
The second also sets goals, but takes the time to understand what motivates people, encourages initiative and creates conditions for staff to be involved in decision-making.
Which of the two is the better leader?
The answer is not quite so simple.
Different situations call for different leadership styles. In a crisis, a quick and clear decision may be necessary. When developing an innovative product, the freedom to experiment, the exchange of ideas and team involvement may be of greater importance.
It is precisely this complexity that lies at the heart of the development of modern leadership theories.
Today, leadership is increasingly viewed not merely as a position within the organisational hierarchy, but as a process of influence, interaction and creating the conditions for achieving common goals.
What does leadership actually mean?
Leadership is a process through which a person influences a group, directs its efforts towards common goals and facilitates coordination amongst participants.
It is not the same as management.
Management involves planning, organising, allocating resources, controlling and coordinating.
Leadership is also linked to setting direction, motivation, trust and a willingness to change.
In real-world organisations, the two functions often overlap.
An effective leader must be able to manage processes and work with people at the same time.
However, ideas about how to achieve such a balance have changed significantly over the years.
Early leadership theories: leaders are born, not made
At the beginning of the 20th century, research into leadership placed a strong emphasis on personality traits.
According to early theories, certain people possess qualities that make them natural leaders.
These often included intelligence, self-confidence, decisiveness, initiative and the ability to influence others.
In some of the early concepts, these qualities were regarded as primarily innate.
Gradually, however, researchers found that personality traits alone were not sufficient to explain leadership effectiveness.
A person may be confident and intelligent, yet fail to manage conflicts or build trust.
Another person may lack the typical charisma we associate with leaders, but achieve excellent results through consistency, competence and good interaction with the team.
Contemporary research shows that personality traits matter, but leadership skills and behaviour can also be developed.
This raises a new question: it
is not just about what sort of person the leader is, but what they do and how their behaviour affects others?
From personality traits to leadership styles
In the mid-20th century, attention gradually shifted towards the observable behaviour of leaders.
Researchers began to distinguish between two main aspects of leadership behaviour.
The first is task orientation – setting goals, organising work, monitoring results and ensuring efficiency.
The second is people orientation – focusing on relationships, support, communication and team development.
These orientations are not necessarily mutually exclusive.
A leader may have high expectations regarding results whilst at the same time showing respect for people.
In fact, much of modern leadership is based precisely on the ability to combine clearly defined expectations with appropriate support.
Transactional leadership: clarity, rules and results
Transactional leadership views the relationship between the manager and employees in terms of clear expectations, responsibilities and consequences.
The leader defines what needs to be achieved, how performance will be assessed, and what rewards or corrective actions are linked to the results.
This approach can be useful in situations where predictability, a clear division of tasks and adherence to established standards are required.
For example, in a manufacturing environment or in activities with high safety requirements, clear rules and monitoring of performance are essential.
Limitations arise when management is reduced solely to control and reward.
In such cases, there may be insufficient scope for initiative, creativity and personal development.
Transactional leadership, however, is not necessarily ineffective or outdated. Research shows that some of its components can contribute positively to management outcomes.
Transformational leadership: inspiration and a shared vision
One of the most influential contemporary models is transformational leadership.
The concept was developed by James McGregor Burns and later expanded upon by Bernard Bass.
A transformational leader does not limit themselves to assigning tasks and monitoring their completion.
They strive to create a shared vision, encourage people’s development and build commitment to common goals.
The model is usually presented through four key components.
1. Idealised influence
The leader demonstrates behaviour that builds respect and trust.
People observe not only what they say, but also how they act.
If a leader demands honesty but covers up their own mistakes, trust gradually diminishes.
2. Inspirational motivation
The leader helps people understand the significance of shared goals.
Rather than simply assigning tasks, they demonstrate why carrying them out matters.
This can be particularly important during organisational changes, when staff need to adapt to new requirements.
3. Intellectual stimulation
A transformational leader encourages asking questions, seeking alternative solutions and critical thinking.
They do not assume that there is only one correct way to carry out a task.
Such behaviour can foster learning and innovation.
4. Individualised approach
The leader recognises the differences between people and their development needs.
One employee may need more guidance, whilst another works better with greater autonomy.
An individualised approach does not mean special privileges, but rather taking into account competencies, responsibilities and the situation.
The 2004 meta-analysis by Judge and Piccolo established positive links between transformational leadership and a number of indicators of leadership effectiveness.
However, this does not mean that the model is universally the best in every organisational situation.
Situational leadership: one style does not fit all
The next important step in the development of leadership theories was the realisation that effectiveness depends on context.
According to contingency approaches, different leadership behaviours can be beneficial under different conditions.
Fred Fiedler, for example, investigated the relationship between a leader’s task- or relationship-orientation and the favourability of a particular situation.
In his model, task-oriented leaders may be more effective in highly favourable or highly unfavourable conditions, whilst relationship-oriented leaders may be more effective under certain intermediate conditions.
This is a specific theoretical model, not a universal rule applicable to all organisations.
Other situational approaches place greater emphasis on adapting leadership behaviour to the competence, experience and needs of employees.
For example, a new employee may need clear instructions, regular feedback and more structured support.
An experienced professional who is familiar with their tasks may be more effective when given autonomy and the opportunity to determine how to carry out their work.
Good leadership does not mean using a single style in every situation, but rather understanding what managerial actions are required in a specific context.
Leading by example: when actions speak louder than words
One of the most recognisable principles of modern leadership is leading by example.
It is based on the idea that a leader’s behaviour sets standards which the team observes and often emulates.
If a manager encourages a work-life balance but sends work-related messages every evening and expects an immediate reply, the actual message is different from the one officially stated.
If they talk about respect but publicly humiliate staff for their mistakes, they can hardly expect open communication.
Leading by example, however, does not mean that the manager must personally carry out all the team’s tasks.
Their role is to demonstrate the standards of behaviour they expect from others.
This includes responsibility, consistency, respect, a willingness to learn and the ability to acknowledge their own mistakes.
Why has trust become the cornerstone of modern leadership?
The more complex and dynamic the working environment becomes, the greater the importance of trust.
In the absence of trust, employees may start to cover up problems, shy away from taking the initiative and limit the sharing of information.
Conversely, when relationships are predictable and fair, people are better placed to collaborate.
But trust is not created by good intentions alone.
It is built through consistent behaviour.
In a 2021 article for the Harvard Business Review, Ron Carucci outlines four practices for building trust based on many years of research into organisational leadership.
His analysis covers over 3,200 leaders over a period of approximately 15 years.
The key message is that reliability and integrity are an important foundation, but they are not sufficient on their own.
Trust also requires concrete actions in day-to-day interactions.
Four practices for building trust within a team
1. Be consistent between your words and actions
Every leader has values that they state publicly or demonstrate through their behaviour.
But employees assess these values first and foremost through actual decisions.
For example, a company may state that it encourages teamwork.
However, if a manager consistently rewards only individual results and overlooks collective contributions, the message loses its impact.
Similarly, a leader who talks about open communication but reacts aggressively to dissent creates a contradiction between the stated and the actual rules.
What can we do in practice?
Choose a few values that you consider key to your management approach.
Then ask yourself how these are reflected in your day-to-day decisions.
If you value respect, how do you react when a mistake is made?
If you value transparency, how do you explain difficult decisions?
If you value development, do you actually set aside time for training and feedback?
No manager is entirely consistent at all times.
But when we spot a discrepancy, it is important to acknowledge it, take responsibility and adjust our behaviour.
2. Treat people and their contributions with respect
Respect goes beyond a polite tone.
It encompasses the way we allocate tasks, evaluate results and acknowledge professional contributions.
An employee may put a great deal of effort into a project but remain demotivated if their work is consistently overlooked.
Another may have a valuable idea but avoid sharing it because previous suggestions have been ignored.
A manager can create opportunities for people to showcase their work, receive the recognition they deserve and participate in decisions relating to their area of expertise.
The attitude towards mistakes is particularly important.
Mistakes require analysis and accountability.
But there is a significant difference between accountability and humiliation.
When a person can admit to a difficulty without fear of being publicly shamed, the organisation gains the opportunity to identify the problem at an earlier stage.
This is closely linked to the concept of psychological safety.
3. Balance transparency with discretion
Trust requires openness, but it does not mean sharing every piece of information unconditionally.
A leader must explain decisions that affect the team’s work and provide sufficient information to enable tasks to be carried out in an informed manner.
At the same time, they have a duty to protect confidential information.
This includes personal data, health information, sensitive organisational matters and individual professional discussions.
For example, if an employee shares a personal problem that is affecting their work, the manager must not disclose the details to other colleagues.
It may be necessary to arrange a temporary change in duties, but without infringing on the person’s privacy.
Transparency and discretion are not opposites.
Both are part of professional conduct that builds trust.
Feedback also plays an important role here.
Managers must not only provide clear and respectful feedback, but also create opportunities for employees to express their observations and suggestions.
4. Foster a sense of belonging and collaboration
In many organisations, individual teams work towards different goals and metrics.
This sometimes creates competition between departments, even when everyone is working for the same organisation.
The leader’s role is to help people understand how their individual tasks contribute to the wider goal.
For example, the sales team and the customer service department may have different priorities.
But if they are united around the goal of a better customer experience, collaboration can become easier.
A sense of belonging is also built through the way people are treated on a day-to-day basis.
This means listening to them, giving them the opportunity to contribute, and ensuring they feel respected regardless of their position.
It is important, however, not to confuse a sense of belonging with the expectation that everyone should think alike or share personal information.
A healthy team allows for differences whilst maintaining common professional standards.
Psychological safety: a new dimension of leadership effectiveness
One of the key themes in contemporary organisational research is psychological safety.
Amy Edmondson defines it as a shared belief that the team allows for the taking of interpersonal risks, such as asking questions, admitting mistakes and expressing a different opinion.
In a study published in 1999, she established a link between psychological safety and learning-related behaviour within teams.
This does not mean that in a psychologically safe environment there are no expectations or criticism.
On the contrary, clear standards and accountability can co-exist with respect and open communication.
For example, when a mistake occurs, a manager might ask:
‘What happened and how can we prevent it from happening again?’
Instead of:
‘Who is to blame and why did you fail again?’
In both cases, the problem is addressed.
But the first approach creates more opportunities for learning, whilst the second may encourage cover-ups and defensive behaviour.
How does leadership style affect stress in the workplace?
Leadership matters not only for business results but also for the conditions in which people work.
The way tasks are set, conflicts are managed and changes are communicated can affect employees’ psychological strain.
For example, unpredictable demands, contradictory instructions, unfair treatment or a lack of support can contribute to psychosocial risks.
On the other hand, clear roles, involvement in decision-making and respectful communication can help to organise work more effectively.
It is important to distinguish good leadership from the idea that a manager must constantly motivate people.
Sometimes the most important managerial decision is to reduce excessive workloads, reallocate resources or eliminate unnecessary conflicts in work processes.
Employees’ psychological resilience is important, but it cannot indefinitely compensate for an unfavourable organisational environment.
That is why modern leadership must encompass not only motivation and development, but also the identification and management of psychosocial risks.
How can we develop leadership skills in practice?
Leadership is not a static set of qualities.
It involves behaviours and skills that can be observed, practised and improved.
It is useful for managers to periodically assess their own behaviour.
For example:
Clarity:
Do people understand what is expected of them and why?
Consistency:
Do my decisions align with the values I profess?
Feedback:
Do I provide specific guidance, and am I open to receiving criticism?
Autonomy:
Do I give people sufficient freedom in line with their competencies?
Respect:
How do I react when someone makes a mistake or expresses disagreement?
Sustainability:
Do I create the conditions for achieving results without systematically exhausting the team?
The answers can serve as a starting point for targeted development.
It is not necessary to change all skills at once.
It is often more useful to choose one specific practice and observe how its implementation affects the team’s work.
Leadership of the future: adaptability, trust and accountability
Organisations are changing.
Technology is automating tasks, teams are working in different locations, and the requirements for professional competencies are evolving rapidly.
In this environment, leadership cannot be based solely on formal authority or individual expertise.
Managers must be able to make decisions in conditions of uncertainty, foster collaboration and create conditions for continuous learning.
This does not mean that hierarchy, rules and control are becoming irrelevant.
It means that they must be combined with trust, transparency and a respectful approach to people.
A modern leader does not necessarily need to have an answer to every question.
It is more important to be able to organise a process in which the necessary knowledge, different perspectives and professional skills can be utilised effectively.
Trust is built every day
There is no single universal leadership style that guarantees success in every situation.
Effective leadership depends on the tasks, the people, the organisational environment and the leader’s ability to adapt their behaviour.
But regardless of the specific style, one factor remains particularly important – trust.
It is not earned solely through one’s position, authority or good intentions.
It is built through consistent actions, respect, fairness and a willingness to take responsibility.
Ultimately, employees judge leaders not only by the strategies they present or the results they achieve.
They also remember the way they have been treated.
Good leadership is not measured solely by how successfully a leader achieves their goals, but also by the conditions they create for the people involved in achieving them.
Scientific sources
- Stogdill, R. M. (1948). Personal Factors Associated with Leadership: A Survey of the Literature. The Journal of Psychology, 25(1), 35–71. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223980.1948.9917362
- Fiedler, F. E. (1967). A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness. McGraw-Hill.
- Burns, J. M. (1978). Leadership. Harper & Row.
- Bass, B. M. (1990). From Transactional to Transformational Leadership: Learning to Share the Vision. Organisational Dynamics, 18(3), 19–31. https://doi.org/10.1016/0090-2616(90)90061-S
- Judge, T. A., & Piccolo, R. F. (2004). Transformational and Transactional Leadership: A Meta-Analytic Test of Their Relative Validity. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(5), 755–768. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.89.5.755
- Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological Safety and Learning Behaviour in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
- Carucci, R. (2021). Build Your Reputation as a Trustworthy Leader. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2021/06/build-your-reputation-as-a-trustworthy-leader
- World Health Organisation. (2022). WHO Guidelines on Mental Health at Work. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240053052
Workplace bullying: What is it and how should we respond?
