..Without demotivating people?
Feedback is one of the most important tools in people management. It can encourage development, improve results and strengthen trust within the team. But when delivered incorrectly, it can trigger a defensive reaction, insecurity and a loss of motivation.
Imagine you have to tell a colleague that they haven’t performed well on an important task. You want to be honest, but you don’t want to upset them. You wonder whether to start with praise, how to phrase the criticism and how to avoid tension.
Conversations like these are part of every manager’s daily routine. Nevertheless, giving feedback remains one of the most difficult management skills.
The reason is simple: when we comment on someone’s performance, we are not just discussing results. We are also touching on the way a person perceives their own abilities, competence and professional worth.
That is why good feedback requires not only a clear message, but also respect, understanding and a willingness to engage in dialogue.
Why is feedback so important?
Without feedback, it is difficult to understand which of our actions lead to good results and what we need to change.
We may put a great deal of effort into our work, but if we do not know how our results are assessed, we are left wondering whether we are moving in the right direction.
Positive feedback shows us which behaviours and decisions are effective and worth continuing.
Corrective feedback helps us to identify shortcomings, acquire new skills and improve our performance.
But there is one important point to note: not all feedback leads to improvement.
In a large-scale meta-analysis, psychologists Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNizzi (1996) found that, on average, feedback improves performance, but in more than a third of the cases analysed, the effect was negative.
This means that simply providing feedback is not enough. The way in which it is formulated and received is of crucial importance.
What is the difference between criticism and constructive feedback?
Although we often use the terms as synonyms, there is an important difference between them.
Criticism usually focuses on the mistake or shortcoming.
Constructive feedback focuses on specific behaviour, its consequences and opportunities for improvement.
For example:
Criticism:
‘You never meet deadlines. You can’t be relied upon.’
Constructive feedback:
“Over the last two weeks, the reports were sent after the agreed deadline. This has held up the team’s preparations. Let’s discuss what’s making it difficult to meet deadlines and how we can improve our organisation.”
In the second instance, the problem is not glossed over. On the contrary, it is clearly identified.
The difference is that the conversation does not attack the person’s character, but creates an opportunity for understanding and action.
The aim of constructive feedback is not to prove who was at fault, but to help improve the situation.
Why does negative feedback sometimes provoke a defensive reaction?
When we receive criticism, especially if it is unexpected or delivered harshly, we may perceive it as a threat to our own competence or social standing.
In such situations, a person may start making excuses, denying the problem, remaining silent or reacting emotionally.
This does not necessarily mean that they do not wish to improve.
Sometimes the way the message is delivered makes it difficult to take on board useful information.
Research shows that feedback directed at the individual may be less effective than feedback that focuses on the specific task and the necessary actions.
For example, the phrase ‘You’re not good at communicating’ can be perceived as a judgement on the person’s character.
It is far more helpful to say: ‘During the meeting, several participants did not have the opportunity to express their views. Next time, we could set aside time for questions and discussion.’
In this way, the person receives information they can actually work on.
Seven principles for effective, constructive feedback
1. Be specific, not general
One of the most common mistakes is the use of generalisations.
Phrases such as ‘You’re always late’, ‘You never listen’ or ‘You’re not committed enough’ are rarely helpful.
They can lead to an argument about whether the statement is true, rather than a discussion of the specific problem.
A better approach is to describe observable behaviour.
For example:
‘At the last two meetings, you joined in after the discussion had started and missed some of the information.’
This is specific and can be discussed.
2. Separate behaviour from personality
Feedback should focus on actions, decisions and results, rather than on personal characteristics.
Instead of ‘You’re disorganised’, say:
“I’ve noticed that several tasks have been left without a clear priority or deadline. Let’s discuss how we can organise the work more clearly.”
This way, you’re not labelling the person, but addressing behaviour that can be changed.
3. Choose the right moment
Feedback is most useful when it relates to a current situation.
If you wait a few months, the person may not remember the details or may be surprised that the issue wasn’t discussed earlier.
However, this does not mean you should react immediately in every situation.
If the conversation is emotionally charged, it is wiser to wait until both parties can discuss the matter calmly.
Particularly when the feedback is critical, it is usually more appropriate to have a one-to-one conversation rather than discussing it publicly in front of colleagues.
4. Do not hide criticism behind insincere praise
A popular approach is the so-called ‘sandwich’ method – a positive comment, followed by criticism, and then praise again.
For example:
‘You’re doing a brilliant job. It’s just that the last project was very poorly organised. But otherwise, we’re pleased with you.’
This approach may seem gentler, but it can sometimes obscure the main message.
The person may be left with the impression that the problem isn’t serious, or start to see the praise as a prelude to an unpleasant conversation.
A better option is to be clear and respectful.
“I’d like to discuss how the last project was organised, as there are a few things we could improve.”
Positive feedback is also important, but it must be sincere, specific and linked to actual achievements.
5. Ask questions and listen
Feedback shouldn’t be a monologue.
A manager may have a good idea of the outcome, but may not be aware of all the circumstances that led to it.
That’s why it’s useful to ask questions such as:
- ‘How do you rate the result?’
- “What was the biggest challenge?”
- “What do you think could have been done differently?”
- “What sort of support would help you next time?”
Sometimes we’ll find that the person has made a mistake.
At other times, we’ll realise that the problem stems from unclear instructions, insufficient resources or conflicting expectations.
This information is just as important as the initial assessment.
6. Focus on future improvement
Simply telling someone what they did wrong is not enough.
Effective feedback should also help answer the question: ‘What next?’
For example:
‘Next time, I’d like us to receive weekly updates on the project’s progress. This will enable us to identify any difficulties at an earlier stage.’
It may turn out that training, extra time, better organisation or a change in the allocation of tasks is needed.
A constructive discussion should lead to realistic actions, rather than simply a promise that ‘next time will be better’.
7. Follow up
One of the most overlooked parts of feedback is the follow-up discussion.
If you have discussed a problem and agreed on specific actions, it is important to check what has changed.
This can be done through a brief meeting, a review of the results or a discussion of any difficulties that have arisen.
Following up shows that the aim was not simply to point out the mistake, but to support development.
A practical model for giving feedback
To ensure the conversation is clear, you can use a simple structure based on observation, impact and next steps.
Step one: Describe the specific situation.
“During yesterday’s meeting with the client, the presentation started 15 minutes late.”
Step two: Explain the impact.
“This reduced the time available for questions and meant we had to cut short the presentation of some solutions.”
Step three: Seek the other person’s perspective.
“What do you think caused the delay?”
Step four: Agree on next steps.
“Let’s schedule a technical check in advance for the next meeting and clarify who is responsible for the preparations.”
This structure helps keep the conversation focused on the facts and solutions.
It is not a one-size-fits-all formula. In more complex situations, it is necessary to take into account relationships, context and specific circumstances.
How can we give positive feedback?
Constructive feedback isn’t just about mistakes.
Positive feedback is important because it helps people understand which of their actions are valuable and effective.
But here, too, specificity matters.
Instead of the general ‘Well done, you did a great job’, we could say:
‘The way you structured the presentation and answered the client’s questions helped us reach a decision more quickly. That was very well prepared.’
A message like this does more than just provide satisfaction. It shows which behaviour is worth repeating.
Positive feedback shouldn’t be reserved solely for major successes.
Regularly acknowledging a job well done can boost motivation and a sense of professional competence.
What should we do if someone reacts defensively?
Even when feedback is delivered tactfully, the recipient may react with irritation, denial or disappointment.
Instead of immediately insisting that you are right, try to understand their reaction.
You could say:
“I understand this is an uncomfortable topic. Let’s discuss your point of view as well.”
Or:
‘I may not have all the information. How do you see the situation?’
This does not mean giving up on clearly set expectations.
It means allowing room for dialogue before reaching a final conclusion.
If the conversation becomes too tense, it is sometimes better to continue it later.
The aim is to reach an understanding, not for one side to necessarily win the argument.
Psychological safety and feedback
Feedback does not exist in isolation from the working environment.
If employees are afraid to ask questions, admit mistakes or express a different opinion, even well-formulated criticism can be perceived as a threat.
Psychological safety plays a key role here.
This is the shared sense within a team that people can speak openly, ask questions and admit to difficulties without being humiliated or punished simply for expressing an opinion.
Amy Edmondson’s research highlights the importance of psychological safety for learning and behaviour within teams.
This does not mean an absence of expectations or accountability.
On the contrary, a healthy working environment combines clear standards with respect, the opportunity for discussion and support when needed.
When people trust that feedback is aimed at improvement rather than humiliation, they are better placed to use it constructively.
Feedback as part of good leadership
The ability to give feedback is directly linked to the way we lead people.
A manager is not solely responsible for setting targets and monitoring performance.
They also play a vital role in creating an environment in which employees understand expectations, receive the necessary support and have the opportunity to develop their skills.
Effective feedback is part of this process.
It must be regular, fair, specific and tailored to the actual scope for change.
It is also important for managers to be prepared to receive feedback themselves.
This is because trust is not built solely by telling others what to improve, but also by demonstrating that we are prepared to reconsider our own decisions.
You can read more about the development of management approaches in the article ‘The Evolution of Leadership Approaches and Styles’.
Can inappropriate feedback become a source of stress?
Yes. Especially when the criticism is constant, unpredictable, humiliating or not accompanied by clear expectations.
In such a working environment, people may begin to fear making mistakes, avoid taking the initiative and feel insecure about their own performance.
Feedback that systematically undermines confidence and offers no real opportunities for improvement can become an additional psychosocial risk factor.
It is therefore important, when assessing the working environment, to consider not only workload and deadlines, but also the quality of managerial relationships, the clarity of expectations and the way in which mistakes are discussed.
When feedback forms part of a consistent and fair management practice, it can support development rather than creating additional stress.
You can read more about organisational approaches to prevention in ‘Workplace Stress and Psychosocial Risks: Programmes for Organisations’.
Good feedback starts with respect
Not every conversation needs to be pleasant.
Sometimes we need to make it clear that certain behaviour is unacceptable, that results are not meeting expectations, or that a significant change is needed.
But even a difficult conversation can be conducted in a way that preserves the person’s dignity.
Constructive feedback does not mean avoiding criticism. It means turning it into useful information that facilitates understanding, development and action.
A good manager is not someone who never offers criticism. It is someone who knows how to point out difficulties clearly, to listen and to create realistic conditions for improvement.
Ultimately, feedback is most valuable not when it proves who is right, but when it helps people and teams to work better together.
Scientific sources
- Kluger, A. N., & DeNisi, A. (1996). The Effects of Feedback Interventions on Performance: A Historical Review, a Meta-Analysis, and a Preliminary Feedback Intervention Theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254–284. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.119.2.254
- Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The Power of Feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81–112. https://doi.org/10.3102/003465430298487
- Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological Safety and Learning Behaviour in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
- Chappelow, C., & McCauley, C. (2019). What Good Feedback Really Looks Like. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2019/05/what-good-feedback-really-looks-like
- Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD). (2022). Performance Feedback: An Evidence Review. https://www.cipd.org/en/knowledge/evidence-reviews/performance-feedback/
- Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD). Trust and Psychological Safety: An Evidence Review. https://www.cipd.org/uk/knowledge/evidence-reviews/trust-psychological-safety
Mental health in the workplace: the HR perspective
Workplace bullying: What is it and how should we respond?
